Yamuna River: Is the BJP Government Using Chhath Puja for Political Publicity While the Reality Remains Different?

Image Credit: Manishjaisi via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 . Photo taken on 2 November 2019.
Why Is the Yamuna River Becoming a Political Issue?
BJP leaders and ministers seem to have turned even the Yamuna River into a political issue. Chhath Puja has just taken place. There is no question of opposing the festival or the religious sentiments of the people. But the question is: Is the BJP government using Chhath Puja for political publicity?
Why am I raising this question?
Just before Chhath Puja, news reports and political claims suggested that the BJP government had completely cleaned the Yamuna River. The message was that the previous government could not clean the river, but the BJP government had finally achieved what others failed to do.
But what is the actual situation on the ground?
If the Yamuna has really been cleaned, why are people still facing such conditions during Chhath Puja? And why is the government presenting a different picture from what people can see with their own eyes?
Why Are Separate Arrangements Being Made for Leaders and Ministers?
Another important question needs an answer. Why are separate arrangements being made for Chhath Puja, including what appears to be a separate water body or river-like arrangement?
Why are special arrangements made for leaders and ministers? Why can’t ordinary people receive the same facilities? Why are separate arrangements not made for the general public so that they can celebrate the festival in clean and safe water?
Look at the condition of the Yamuna where people have gathered to perform Chhath Puja. The water appears visibly polluted, with foam and other signs of contamination.
If the river is completely clean, then why does the situation look so different?
The BJP government needs to answer these questions.
Manoj Tiwari Should Drink This Water and Take a Dip Here
A few days ago, a video went viral showing BJP leader Manoj Tiwari drinking water from the Yamuna and taking a dip in the river. Media reports also highlighted claims that the water had become so clean that it was fit to drink.
Fine. If the Yamuna water is really that clean, then Manoj Tiwari ji should come to the very spot where ordinary people are standing during Chhath Puja.
Drink the water from this exact location. Take a dip here. Show people that the claims being made about the Yamuna are actually true.
It is easy to demonstrate cleanliness at one selected location. But the real condition of the river must be judged by looking at the places where ordinary people are actually performing religious rituals.
If the government says the Yamuna is clean, let the public see that claim being proved on the ground.
Who Will Be Responsible If People Fall Sick?
Thousands of people are coming into contact with the Yamuna water during Chhath Puja. If people develop skin problems or fall ill after taking a dip in polluted water, who will take responsibility?
Will the government answer?
People have the right to know whether the water is safe. Religious faith is one thing, but public health is another. The government cannot ignore the health risks of ordinary citizens.
And why are these ground realities not receiving the same attention as the claims of a completely cleaned Yamuna?
People can see the condition of the river themselves. They do not need someone to tell them what to believe.
Is Mainstream Media Showing the Complete Reality?
Another question is for mainstream media.
When reports and videos claim that the Yamuna has become completely clean, why isn’t the media showing the actual condition of the river at the locations where people are performing Chhath Puja?
Are news channels giving more attention to the government’s claims than to the questions being raised by ordinary people?
If the media shows people taking a dip in visibly polluted water, viewers can judge the situation for themselves.
The media should ask the government difficult questions instead of simply repeating political claims. Its responsibility is to show both the government’s statements
